Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Products and services not directly necessary for sustenance exist only because of advertising.

If you are employed in an industry other than agriculture, textiles, or residential construction, there would be no work for you or any of your coworkers without advertising. If people's basic urges do not require them to give you money, then there is no money with which to write your paycheck.

Obviously it can be taken too far, but eliminating advertising from the world in all forms is probably not what you want.



I don't understand how you reach the conclusion that people would not purchase products that they do not need to live if not for advertisements.

Would you mind explaining your reasoning for that?


Sure. Advertising is the craft of getting people to want things, then positioning a particular product as the best (or only) way to satisfy that want.

If you want something not embedded in your biology (i.e. food, sex, temperature regulation) then you want it because of advertising - either media you were exposed to, people who influenced you to want it, or just seeing the product out in the street. If you are aware of a particular product or vendor at all, it is because of advertising.

Of the people in the world who are economically useful, they are useful only insofar as as people want the things they help produce. Without advertising, people want only food, shelter, water, sex, etc. Without advertising, people are entirely unaware of where they can exchange money for anything they want, biologically necessary or not.

A world without advertising is a world without trade. The only way that could ever really happen is a centrally planned economy with resources handed out; the second you have something resembling a market, the way sellers and buyers discover each other is advertising.


Hm. If I understand you correctly, you're saying that children would not want to be told stories, without advertising?

I mean, I agree people need to be aware of a good or service to buy it (and that includes food, sex, and temperature regulation -- not sure why you've got a special case for them). But I think there's a distinction between making that information available for people seeking things out (like, having a stall at a market that carries your product) and bombarding people with messages about it at all hours of the day.


Advertising to people with intent to buy is still advertising, just the most lucrative and expensive kind.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: