Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Districts should be deprecated altogether. Instead we should elect representatives via proportional representation.

When we we had approximately 30,000 citizens per representative there was a chance at your representative actually knowing you, but at this point we are more likely to have our views represented by a third party.



Norway is below your 30,000 citizen per representative number, and frankly even then, while there certainly is a chance, not many people do know their representative even there.

In Norway, some regional connection is arranged by grouping seats into multi-seatconstituencies by region. Then more proportional results are obtained by taking any votes "leftover" for a party after assigning whole seats and assigning seats from a non-geographic pool with some caveats.

It satisfies those who want a regional link of sorts, and doesn't skew the proportionality too much.


For the US, I think that electing representatives by proportional representation within states would work similarly and would work pretty well with our existing constitutional framework.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: