It reminds me of the Star Wars content thats come out recently - before there wa...

mghackerlady · 2026-02-26T17:16:17 1772126177

Rogue One was very good, to the point that I consider it on equal standing to the original trilogy and prequels

adammarples · 2026-02-26T17:44:16 1772127856

It's a blur of mediocrity due to its mediocrity, not its overexposure

camdenreslink · 2026-02-26T18:30:28 1772130628

Yea, if the new stuff coming out was great then people would be begging for more.

hackyhacky · 2026-02-26T17:08:22 1772125702

> except The Mandalorian,

To each their own, but I think Andor is, by far, the best post-ROTJ output.

mcny · 2026-02-26T17:52:02 1772128322

> To each their own,

And that is the gist of the problem, isn't it? As we approach our forties and beyond, chances are we have lived more than half our lives. So do I really want to spend hours watching something I might hate and might leave a bad taste in my mouth? (See game of thrones season 8 or worse, Westworld the HBO series which I don't even want to know what happened in season 3 or 4). I am sure there are people who will enjoy those but for the average person it is highly unlikely.

the_af · 2026-02-26T18:43:40 1772131420

> except The Mandalorian

Mandalorian started strong, with cool spaghetti Western vibes, and then ended up devolving into mediocrity too. In my opinion.

Haven't watched Andor yet.

mrec · 2026-02-26T20:07:37 1772136457

Andor is fantastic, but I think it's important to set expectations before going in. Compared to other SW content it's much slower-paced and more restrained/cerebral.

Mandalorian didn't do much for me; too gamey/Marvel-ey/cartooney.

the_af · 2026-02-26T22:26:19 1772144779

I've heard Andor described as having the same vibe as The Mandalorian's episode "The Convert"; the one about the former Imperial scientist being rehabilitated and living in an apartment block with other former Imperials.

If so, I will like Andor. I really liked "The Convert".

pavo-etc · 2026-02-27T04:09:46 1772165386

The quality difference between Andor and The Mandalorian is so stark that I don't even think they are comparable. The Convert is a fine episode I guess, but next to Andor it's amateur.

Andor is prestige TV. The Mandolorian feels like a childrens show by comparison.

If you think The Convert was good, please, please watch Andor.

duderific · 2026-02-26T22:41:43 1772145703

I quite literally couldn't stay awake for Andor. Five minutes into each episode I was out cold. Saying it's a "slow burn" is quite the understatement.

TaupeRanger · 2026-02-26T17:08:46 1772125726

Andor is fantastic. The good content still stands out. Mediocre content will have to compete with AI slop at an increasing rate.

ex-aws-dude · 2026-02-26T17:49:48 1772128188

That is something that annoys me with fandoms

You could ask "how many more movies should we make?" and the answer would be "there is no limit, I always want more"

"I like this thing therefore more of it is obviously better"

I think it takes maturity to say "I like this thing and I don't want more of it."

the_af · 2026-02-26T18:47:23 1772131643

Yes, and also many fandoms lack the maturity to know when to say "no, I do not want to know MORE details, and certainly not about this obscure secondary character's difficult childhood that explains everything they did later in life".

See:

- All of Wookiepedia and most of Star Wars Expanded Universe.

- "The Hunt for Gollum".

- Every movie in the franchise after "Alien" and "Aliens".

- The sadly upcoming expanded universe/sequels/shows for Blade Runner.

Etc, etc. Everyone has their exceptions ("this one was cool"), but in general the point stands: fandoms ruin everything. They simply don't believe in the adage that "less is more". They always want MORE, and the industry is only happy to oblige.