Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It is a refreshing point of view. We, the generation of city-dwellers, no longer understand the foundation upon which our city wealth rests. For us, the farmland is "an unimportant middle of nowhere" and we see the ultimate worth in some cities that, if looked from the article's POV, can be easily discarded without any change in the world power/wealth balance.

It seems that grain meant the same in 19 century that oil means today. And for grain, you need a lot of territory with population and transportation and security. With oil it's different, you have to be lucky and here it is: population isn't that important anymore, neither is territory per se.



If oil is so important, then why is there no Middle Eastern superpower?


Oil is important but it does not make you powerful per se.

Oil plus security might. But Middle Eastern countries have no security.


Oil and resources in general are only useful to societies that know how to use them properly. To many countries, oil is a curse: http://dean2004.blogspot.com/2009/02/zakaria-on-curse-of-oil...

It's like chess, checkers, risk, go, Starcraft, etc.

You can put a crappy player in a great position on the board, giving them great "resources". But a significantly better player will often still be able to win.

Compare North Korea to South Korea. Same culture, same geography, same genetic pool -- but as a society the North Koreans went horribly horribly wrong. North Koreans went with a political and economic philosophy (communism) that was and is far inferior to capitalism.

That's my fundamental disagreement with this article. Human intellect driven by forces in the culture and society have a great more to do with a country's "importance" on the geopolitical stage than resources.


Even if you know how to use them properly you might be limited in your ability to do so due to the weakness of your geopolitical shape.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: