Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Markets will drift towards efficiency without considering externalities. Markets will not drift towards strategic manufacturing capacity at a higher cost per unit produced without government intervention (subsidies, tariffs.)

Well, and why would we expect them to take that into account?

Btw, there are good and (mostly) bad ways to do these interventions. Tariffs are especially bad.

A lot of the discussion of these measures also treats all foreigners the same. Eg in practice a chip being produced in eg Canada is virtually as good for national security as one produced in the US. But acts like the 'CHIPS and Science Act' don't see it that way.



Yes, tariffs are especially bad if you want to get paid big bucks for the genius business plan of overseeing labor and environmental arbitrage.

The US industrialized itself with tariffs and deindustrialized itself by removing them.


If restrictions to trade are so great, why do nations inevitably try to blockade each others ports in a war? Shouldn't that just help the other guy's economy prosper?


If a massage is so great, why not crush your torso in a hydraulic press? Shouldn't that just be a better massage?


I interpret your quip as saying that you approve of carefully measured and dosed protectionism?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: