Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | wkaisertexas's commentslogin

Those are not affiliate links.

I just found the idea of the ring being paid for by the IRS funny.


Dammit, they should be!


You are in the same tax bracket at $80 and $100k, so the amount that you would pay would be identical.

Switching tax brackets is a categorical change which needs to occur before there is a difference.


Yep! This post was specific to US federal taxes.

If people find this interesting, I will open-source and allow contributions to support other country's tax systems.


A married couple pays the same income tax as two single payers making half the income.

Due to progressive taxation, we tax two people who make $50,000 less than someone who makes $100,000 which is where the tax savings come from.


What is very strange is that some states let you file jointly to save money on federal income taxes, but file separately for state income taxes and others do not.

Taxation is a strange, mixed-up world.


If NIIT significantly outweighs the increase in your standard deduction, you probably already have a tax professional for questions.


A Federal Tax calculator I made after finding out my tax savings would be $12k if I married my girlfriend.


Divorce is way more expensive than your savings. I went through this; you save $12-16k/yr for 10 years and if you invest the difference smartly, it's $300k.

Without a prenup, and most don't cover earnings during your marriage anyway (They're hard to keep updated yearly), you're giving away half in California, which can be over $1M if you're a diligent saver and investor. Then if your spouse is REALLY nasty, you'll owe her spousal support that can be thousands per month, depending on your income (and income POTENTIAL), for the rest of her life (after 10 years of marriage in CA).

Any cost savings are completely nullified by divorce if you're a high earner and almost never make sense. Don't get married for tax savings, marry for other reasons and have the most iron-clad prenup you can afford and get your partner to agree to. I promise you, your future self will thank you.


Marriage seems like a dated concept from when traditional gender roles were a thing, and men and women worked more as a team because they needed each other. Now that they don’t, with the high divorce rates and the high risks for men I can’t see a reason anyone would want to get married, especially outside the US where there’s minimal tax benefits.


Small correction here, its high risk for the higher earner not men specifically.


Sadly accurate - and what is worse is that child support laws by state [0] are actually even more dated in their mechanisms, where despite using an "income shares" model, most don't take custody & parenting time into account.

So despite "savings" from a MFJ filing status, when you go back to Single filer or HOH filer, you're penalized on the child support side.

[0] https://www.ncsl.org/research/human-services/guideline-model...


Actually, you don't care if your partner agrees to the prenup. You care that your partner's lawyer (you can't have the same lawyer for this) agrees to the prenup. The reason for this is that there are judges that are hostile to prenups and you need evidence that your partner made an informed and explicit agreement.

Also don't add sunset clauses because those are ticking time bombs. There is nothing worse than having a stable marriage only for a looming deadline to change the incentives towards instability.


If you stay married for at least ten years, and one spouse has a significantly better social security record, the other spouse can claim spousal benefits if your marriage is still in force or they are unmarried.

Hard to value that though.


Depending on circumstances, you might save considerably more in other areas - being covered as a spouse on the other's employer health insurance, reduced car insurance rates, state & local tax savings, ...


12k in savings included about 6k in state tax savings because I am in California. Will add in state taxes if people end up using this


a pretty fratty attempt at events management with a interesting rotating qr code feature


go to the website linked to check out the github.

Free everywhere except in the United Kingdom and Canada


For 75 total


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: