Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | wiseowise's commentslogin

It’s a less extreme satire for sure.

Which authoritarian government, lmao.

Nazi Germany and America, for two, lmao

America didn’t mandate eugenics in the movie and what does this even have to do with Nazies?

> America didn’t mandate eugenics in the movie

Correct! It mandated eugenics in real life, in the early 20th century. I didn't say that the movie shows eugenics happening. I said "the film itself implies that the idiocracy is due to stupid people breeding more, a classic tenet of Nazism and eugenics alike." Work on your reading comprehension.


> There is nothing in the movie that suggests that the decline in average intelligence is a result of cultural factors or education.

Have you skipped start of the movie or did we watch different editions? They literally open the story with redneck family breeding and spreading their redneck ways through family ties while “smart” family waits for the perfect moment.


I think that the movie makes it really, really obvious that the intellectual degradation goes beyond just culture. The people are presented as being borderline mentally disabled.

https://youtu.be/jbmq9P-8FiM


I rewatched the intro, and it is true that they label the character IQs. That said, I still don't think that the particular mechanism is the most important part

I disagree. I can't imagine any sort of cultural influence that can make grown adults incapable of performing basic tasks that a child could do.

https://youtu.be/jbmq9P-8FiM


...the most important part [of the movie]

Similarly, buildings will probably not topple over and be tethered together with oversized packaging tape

Meanwhile although there's no monster trucks on the White House lawn yet, get ready for UFC Freedom 250


> Meanwhile although there's no monster trucks on the White House lawn yet, Not /currently/... https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/elon-musk/trump-musk-tesla-whit...

Eugenics is artificial. Who’s forcing smart stupid to not breed in the movie and stupid to breed?

Woah, woah, stop right there with your facts Mr. Eugenics. /s

I don’t think that when people say “it’s a documentary” they mean that it’s literally a “documentary”, more like “this satire is so close to reality, that you can call it documentary”.

But we have a term for that and the term is "satire".

It’s a “I’m not like the other ‘not like the other’” virtue game.

> like establishing “stupid people breeding makes stupid people” as incontrovertible fact

That’s based on environment and not on genes. You might not be born “stupid”, but if you’re surrounded by retards (like in the movie), chances are you won’t be splitting atoms.


That’s barely-junior interview question indeed.

> "Cooperative" (as opposed to preemptive) cancel is much cleaner.

Which what Thread.interrupt does.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: