Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | mcji's commentslogin

It all started with the "July 2009 Ürümqi riots" and then escalated after the "2014 Kunming attack".


Can't really collectively punish a community for crimes of few, that's no justice.


I agree wholeheartedly. Let’s discuss this along with lifting collective sanctions imposed on Cuba, Iran, Syria, and Venezuela. That is a form of collective punishments that starves civilians. I’m very cynical about the outrage re: those “re-education” sites. Not because they’re benign but because nobody bats an eye when America commits similarly heinous acts. It seems like a convenient deflection tactic.


Nope. Ban on hi-tech products and weapons do not affect starving civilians in any way, this is solely responsibility of ruling dictators. Exactly like it happened in Russia, in response of banning hi-tech from exporting to Russia, our authorities imposed ban on importing food and medications.


I just wanted to provide some backgrounds.


Yeah, I understand but the background is weak. The majority does feel happy that the outcome was less violence and it doesn't affect them but the question should always be, at what cost.


>"July 2009 Ürümqi riots"

Those were just peaceful protests.


You're referring to the peaceful protests that deteriorated into days of violence which killed 197+ people and injured thousands. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/July_2009_%C3%9Cr%C3%BCmqi_rio...


For what it’s worth, following the thread in the Wikipedia article it looks like the major facts trace back to Chinese state media.


I think OP was not contesting those acts on China were riots, but rather ironically implying that the acts by BLM/Antifa are riots - despite certain media mostly referring to them as 'peaceful protests'.



While US corps predominate,free market is better. Otherwise, controlled market is better. /s


> America is a bully too, but without Uighur concentration camps, fleets of fishing vessels farming the sea to extinction, outrageous claims over the South China Sea, etc.

but with Guantanamo Bay detention camp, bombming Iraq with fabricated evidence and killing hundreds of thousands innocent Iraqi people. Oh, let's not forget how Uncle Sam extended their territory by slaughtering Native Americans since 15th century. You even have a festival to celeberate the genocide and conquest of Native Americans by colonists.


Better not look into Chinese history then


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: